A Comparative Analysis of AI-Generated Intelligence Reports

A closed frontier model writes the better assessment; an auditable platform produces the more defensible one. In high-stakes analysis that trade is not close.

The paper runs the same analytic problem — domestic violent extremist threats to federal buildings during ongoing protests — through two very different tools: GPT-4, a closed-source frontier model, and Recorded Future's AI-enabled threat intelligence platform, which combines open-source models with proprietary aggregation and NLP.